The Prix Goncourt, France's prestigious literary award, has removed a novel from its longlist following accusations that it was authored with the assistance of artificial intelligence. The book, "It Was Either That or Die," by Canadian-Haitian writer Thelyson Orelien, was withdrawn in an effort to maintain the integrity of the prize, according to the Goncourt Academy.

Read More

Orelien, a rising figure in French literature, has denied the claims of AI authorship and suggested that the controversy may be racially motivated as well as an attempt to suppress his voice. He intends to provide evidence to demonstrate that he wrote the novel independently.

The Goncourt Academy stated that "several credible researchers and journalists" have suggested that the book appears to be largely generated by AI. However, the ability to definitively prove AI involvement has proven challenging, with different AI detection tools yielding varying results. Additionally, reports from Quebec have highlighted instances of potential plagiarism, including a 2013 newspaper column by Orelien that was reportedly a close translation of another article, and a novella of his that contained phrases from an older French book.

"It Was Either That or Die" narrates an embellished account of Orelien's life, depicting a fictional character's journey from gang-dominated Haiti to Canada. The novel has been published in over 20 countries, with French rights acquired by Grasset for 300,000 euros.

This incident underscores the difficulties posed by AI detection, reflecting a broader upheaval in creative fields such as literature, music, and design. Alexandre Gefen, a researcher at France's CNRS research institute, remarked that this situation is unprecedented in France and may pave the way for future similar challenges.

Orelien's Canadian publisher, Boreal, halted his promotional events while expressing support for him, noting they could neither confirm nor deny the allegations at present. Grasset also reaffirmed their confidence in Orelien's work.

The allegations first surfaced on an anonymous social media account with few followers, which gained traction when it claimed the novel was predominantly AI-generated. Samuel Fitoussi, a commentator associated with that account, has expressed concerns about AI's potential impact on traditional writing and reading.